Introduction: The Fitness Industry’s Love Affair With Shiny Useless Things
If the fitness industry had a Tinder bio, it would say: “Looking for a quick buck. Swipe right if you like overpriced gear that promises abs in three minutes.”
Today’s right swipe? The weighted vest. You’ve seen them: people strutting around your park looking like underpaid mall cops training for a very slow apocalypse. Influencers swear these vests will give you steel bones, perfect posture, Olympic-level endurance, and maybe even a better personality.
TikTok, of course, is brimming with twenty-somethings promising that wearing ten pounds on your chest while walking to Starbucks will cure menopause, osteoporosis, bad posture, global warming, and your inability to commit to leg day.
But here’s the real question: are weighted vests actually good for bones and muscle, or are they just another expensive security blanket for people who don’t want to buy dumbbells?
Let’s fact-check this fitness fad before you drop $150 on what is basically a sandbag with straps.
Claim #1: Weighted Vests Make Your Bones Stronger
What Influencers Say
Bone density declines with age, especially for women during perimenopause and menopause. Enter the weighted vest, presented as the miracle armor against your bones turning into chalk sticks. Influencers swear it’s like giving your skeleton a gym membership.
What Science Says
Reality check: studies are thin on the ground. One small study compared vest-walkers with non-vest-walkers and—drumroll please—no difference in bone health. Your bones don’t care if you’re wearing a tactical vest full of sand or just strolling in yoga pants.
Another small study found some bone health benefits, but only when people wore vests while doing resistance training. Translation: the bone benefits came from the weights you actually lifted, not the glorified backpack strapped to your torso.
Snarky Truth
If bones could talk, they’d say: “Stop strapping bags of rice to your chest and squat something heavy, you clown.” Weighted vests are not some magical exoskeleton. If you want strong bones, you need weight-bearing resistance training—as in dumbbells, barbells, kettlebells, or literally lifting your dog.
Claim #2: Weighted Vests Build Muscle
What Influencers Say
“Walking with a vest is like strength training lite!” they squeal, usually while filming themselves on a trail with suspiciously good lighting. The idea is that lugging extra pounds will somehow trigger your muscles to balloon like you’re on a Marvel workout plan.
What Science Says
Bad news: walking, even while weighted, doesn’t push muscles hard enough to trigger growth. To grow, muscles need to be challenged through their full range of motion with enough resistance to make them yell, “What fresh hell is this?” That means curls, squats, deadlifts—not mall-walking with an extra ten pounds.
Lauren Colenso-Semple, exercise science researcher, puts it plainly: “Walking and running—with or without a vest—doesn’t stress the muscle enough to make it grow significantly.” Translation: your biceps are not impressed by your cosplay as Batman with extra bricks.
Snarky Truth
Wearing a weighted vest to “build muscle” is like putting a brick in your backpack and calling it CrossFit. You want muscle? Pick up something heavy and put it back down. Repeatedly. Preferably in front of a mirror, while grunting loud enough to annoy everyone else in the gym.
Claim #3: Weighted Vests Improve Posture
What Influencers Say
Apparently, strapping a mini-fridge to your torso will somehow pull your spine into perfect alignment. Some TikTokers swear that wearing a vest turns them into posture models who could balance a wine glass on their heads.
What Science Says
Sorry folks, posture is about muscular balance and strength, not adding random weight. A vest won’t fix your hunched-over laptop neck any more than buying a $400 ergonomic chair fixes your refusal to stretch.
If anything, a poorly fitted vest could make posture worse, dragging you forward like you’re carrying a toddler that refuses to be put down.
Snarky Truth
Want better posture? Do rows, pull-aparts, yoga, or—here’s a radical idea—sit up straight. Weighted vests don’t teach your spine manners.
Claim #4: Weighted Vests Torch Calories
What Influencers Say
This one at least sounds plausible: carry more weight, burn more calories. Walk heavier, lose weight faster.
What Science Says
Finally, a nugget of truth! Roger Fielding of Tufts University confirms that yes, adding weight does increase energy expenditure. More weight = more calorie burn. But here’s the kicker: the difference isn’t huge unless you’re strapping on a vest heavy enough to make airport security tackle you.
And of course, calorie burn doesn’t equal fat loss unless you, you know, stop eating like a raccoon in a Taco Bell dumpster.
Snarky Truth
Weighted vests can help you burn extra calories, but so would carrying a bag of groceries, a child, or your crippling existential dread. If you want weight loss, the boring truth remains: eat less, move more. Sorry, no shortcuts.
Claim #5: Weighted Vests Are Especially Great for Menopause
What Influencers Say
The marketing goldmine: “Attention women over 40! Stop osteoporosis with this one weird trick: buy this $120 vest.” The promise is irresistible—fight bone loss without scary weights or gyms.
What Science Says
OB-GYN experts like Monica Christmas and Nanette Santoro are… unimpressed. They recommend resistance training, Pilates, balance work—not novelty vests. Santoro bluntly calls them out as overpriced gimmicks exploiting women’s fears about aging.
Snarky Truth
Weighted vests are basically the Goop candle of fitness for menopausal women: overpriced, overhyped, and designed to make someone else rich. If you want strong bones, resistance training and adequate protein are your real friends—not a sandbag vest marketed by a TikToker with an affiliate code.
But Wait, Are Weighted Vests Completely Useless?
No. They do offer:
-
Cardio Boost: Walking with weight makes your heart and lungs work harder.
-
Calorie Burn: A smidge more energy used per walk.
-
Fun Factor: Some people just enjoy wearing them. One Colorado workshop leader bragged that everyone knows she “means business” when she’s out walking in her vest. Cool flex.
And honestly? If wearing one motivates you to move more, that’s still better than being a couch ornament.
Why Fitness Fads Like This Keep Happening
Weighted vests are just the latest in a long line of ridiculous fitness trends:
-
Shake Weights (a.k.a. simulated porn in your living room).
-
Sauna suits (a.k.a. sweat-inducing trash bags).
-
ThighMasters (Suzanne Somers, bless you).
-
Vibration plates (“Stand here and jiggle your fat away!”).
Why do these fads thrive? Because people desperately want shortcuts. Nobody wants to hear the boring truth that bone and muscle health requires years of progressive strength training, consistency, and actual effort.
Weighted vests feed the fantasy: buy one product, and you’ll suddenly be healthy. It’s fitness MLM in disguise.
The Bottom Line
-
For Bones: Nope. Get under a barbell, not a vest.
-
For Muscles: Double nope. Vests are extra luggage, not growth stimulators.
-
For Posture: Laughably no. Try stretching.
-
For Calories: Sure, but so does carrying your cat around the block.
-
For Menopause: Please. Save your money.
Final Snarky Take
Weighted vests are not evil. They’re not even particularly dangerous. They’re just… meh. A novelty item that looks badass but delivers little beyond sweat and a few extra burned calories.
So if you like strutting around your neighborhood looking like you’re training for a zombie apocalypse? Knock yourself out. Just don’t fool yourself into thinking your bones are morphing into vibranium.
If your goal is bone density and muscle? Do what the science says: lift heavy things, consistently, forever.