From Sears to Speakeasies: How Private Clubs Are Eating the Mall

Once upon a time, the American mall had anchors. Big ones. Literal temples of mass consumption where you could buy socks, a lawn chair, a microwave, and a sense of mild despair all under one fluorescent roof. Sears. JCPenney. Macy’s. These weren’t just stores — they were civic infrastructure. They told you where to park, where to enter, and how long you’d probably stay before questioning your life choices.

Now? The anchor tenant isn’t a department store. It’s a members-only club with a wine director, a velvet rope, and initiation fees that quietly scream, this space is not for everyone, and that’s the point.

Welcome to the new American retail reality, where malls aren’t dying — they’re being privatized, curated, and filtered for income, taste, and social signaling. The escalator that once took you to bed linens now takes you to a speakeasy. The old food court has been replaced by a tasting menu. And the biggest draw in the shopping center isn’t a sale — it’s access.

This isn’t a quirky lifestyle trend. It’s a structural shift in how commercial real estate survives in a deeply unequal economy. And it tells you more about where America is headed than any quarterly retail earnings report ever could.

The K-Shaped Mall: Where Value Shoppers Go Left and VIPs Go Upstairs

The phrase “K-shaped economy” gets thrown around a lot, but nowhere is it more visible than in retail geography. On one side of the K, shoppers are chasing discounts, clearance racks, and survival math. On the other, people are paying four figures just to walk through the door — and then paying again for cocktails, events, and a sense of belonging.

If you want to see this split in physical form, look at what’s replacing empty retail square footage.

At the lower end: dollar stores, liquidation chains, discount grocers, and post-bankruptcy holdovers clinging to relevance like a mall Santa in February.

At the upper end: private clubs.

Not gyms. Not movie theaters. Not even co-working spaces alone. Actual, members-only social clubs that double as restaurants, galleries, networking hubs, and lifestyle signaling devices.

This is not accidental. Retail landlords have learned a brutal lesson over the last decade: foot traffic doesn’t matter if it doesn’t spend, and volume doesn’t matter if it doesn’t linger.

Private clubs solve both problems at once.

Why Landlords Love Clubs More Than They Ever Loved Sears

From a real estate perspective, private clubs are borderline irresistible.

A traditional anchor store might bring a customer in once or twice a week. A club member comes back multiple times — sometimes daily. Breakfast meeting. Afternoon coffee. Evening drinks. Weekend brunch. Special events. Guest visits. Repeat, repeat, repeat.

That’s dwell time. And dwell time is the most underrated currency in retail.

The longer someone stays on a property, the more likely they are to spend — not just inside the club, but across the entire retail ecosystem surrounding it. That Hermès boutique next door? Suddenly it’s not relying on random walk-ins. It’s feeding off a steady stream of affluent, time-rich customers who are already dressed well, already in “experience mode,” and already primed to spend.

From the landlord’s perspective, this is a dream scenario:

Long-term leases
Predictable traffic
Built-in exclusivity
No need for mass marketing
Customers who don’t flinch at price tags

Compared to chasing another big-box retailer that might vanish in five years, a private club feels like stability with a dress code.

Retail Isn’t Dying — It’s Being Rewritten as a Social Filter

The old model of retail was transactional. You went in, you bought something, you left. The new model is experiential — but not in the “escape room and axe throwing” way malls tried a few years ago.

This version of experience is quieter, more curated, and more exclusionary.

Private clubs aren’t just selling food or drinks. They’re selling:

Access
Familiar faces
A controlled environment
Predictability
Status without spectacle

In a post-pandemic world where public spaces feel increasingly chaotic, the appeal is obvious. You know who’s inside. You know what kind of behavior is expected. You know the staff. You know the menu. You know the lighting won’t be harsh and the music won’t be too loud.

It’s retail as refuge — but only if you can afford the cover charge.

From Coastal Elites to Flyover Luxe

For years, private clubs were associated with places like New York, Los Angeles, and London. They felt imported, rarefied, and slightly ridiculous outside those contexts.

That’s no longer true.

Now they’re showing up in mid-sized cities, suburban retail villages, and downtowns that used to struggle to fill space. Cities that five years ago wouldn’t have supported a private club suddenly can — not because everyone got richer, but because a small, influential segment did.

What changed?

Remote work. Tech money. Entrepreneurial clustering. A professional class untethered from offices but still hungry for connection and distinction.

In these markets, the club isn’t competing with an abundance of elite options. It is the elite option. And that makes it even more powerful as a retail anchor.

The Mall, Reimagined as a Gated Community

There’s a strange irony here. Early suburban malls were explicitly designed as community spaces. They were meant to be public, accessible, and central to everyday life.

Private clubs flip that logic on its head.

They restore the mall’s social function — but behind a paywall.

Instead of a public square, you get a semi-private salon. Instead of teenagers loitering, you get curated networking. Instead of seasonal kiosks, you get art installations and invite-only events.

This is the mall becoming a gated community.

Not physically gated — but economically filtered.

Membership Is the New Discount

Retail used to lure customers with coupons. Now it lures them with membership.

This shift isn’t limited to private clubs. Gyms, co-working spaces, even some retailers have moved toward recurring fees. But clubs take it to its logical extreme: you pay not to save money, but to spend it in a better environment.

That’s a massive psychological inversion.

Membership used to mean loyalty rewards. Now it means belonging.

And belonging is far more powerful — and profitable — than a 20% off coupon.

The Soho House Problem: When Exclusivity Scales Too Fast

Of course, this model isn’t bulletproof.

Private clubs are notoriously vulnerable to overexpansion. The very thing that makes them attractive — exclusivity — is the first thing to break when growth becomes the priority.

Soho House is the cautionary tale everyone in this space pretends not to think about. Rapid expansion. Public markets. Pressure to grow membership. Diluted cachet. And eventually, a retreat back into private ownership at roughly the same valuation it debuted with years earlier.

The lesson is simple: exclusivity doesn’t scale like fast casual dining.

Once a club feels crowded, common, or transactional, it loses the magic that justified the initiation fee in the first place.

Why This Works Right Now — and Might Not Later

Private clubs are thriving because current conditions are perfect:

High-income households are still spending
Social fragmentation makes curated spaces appealing
Retail landlords are desperate for reliable tenants
Experience matters more than inventory

But this is still a cyclical business.

Economic downturns hit discretionary spending first. Clubs rely on members feeling secure enough to pay thousands for access they don’t strictly need. If confidence cracks, cancellations follow.

Retail landlords know this. They’re not betting on clubs as permanent saviors — they’re betting on them as bridges.

A way to stabilize properties, attract the right traffic, and buy time while the next iteration of retail takes shape.

What Comes After the Club?

That’s the real question.

Private clubs are not the end state. They’re a symptom — of inequality, of changing social habits, of retail’s struggle to remain relevant in a digital world.

They are the mall’s way of saying: If we can’t be everything to everyone anymore, we’ll be something exceptional to a few.

Whether that’s sustainable depends on how many people are left outside the velvet rope — and how long those inside feel comfortable pretending the rope doesn’t exist.

Final Thought: The Future of Retail Isn’t Empty — It’s Selective

The American mall isn’t dead. It’s just stopped pretending to be democratic.

Where Sears once stood, there’s now a lounge. Where clearance racks once ruled, there’s curated scarcity. Where everyone was welcome, now you need an invitation — or at least a credit check.

Private clubs aren’t saving retail. They’re redefining who retail is for.

And that might be the most honest evolution the mall has ever undergone.

Search This Blog

eOpicle