Apparently, America Is Sick Because Republicans Lost an Election. Somebody Call a Doctor, Preferably One Who Accepts Reality.
I've been watching American politics long enough to recognize the five stages of Republican grief. There's denial, anger, blaming the media, blaming the voters, and finally announcing that civilization itself is collapsing because Democrats won something. Bargaining rarely makes an appearance. Apparently, negotiating with reality is considered a dangerous liberal activity.
And here we are again.
Following the Republican Party's spectacular performance in the November 2026 midterm elections, by which I mean the political equivalent of driving a car into a swimming pool and then blaming the water, some evangelical leaders in Houston have decided that the problem isn't necessarily Republican policies, Republican candidates, or Republican behavior.
No, ladies and gentlemen. The problem is America.
America is sick. America is spiritually deteriorating. America has apparently wandered so far from righteousness that voting for a Democrat now qualifies as a symptom of some terrible national disease.
I suppose the only available treatment is another Republican administration, preferably administered intravenously while someone reads the Ten Commandments over a loudspeaker.
According to reporting from the Houston Chronicle, James Buntrock, a leader associated with My God Votes and Houston's Glorious Way Church, declared that the nation's culture was "very, very sick." He also warned that America's window of mercy was closing.
Well, isn't that convenient?
I've noticed something fascinating about these declarations of national spiritual emergency. They tend to arrive with remarkable punctuality whenever conservative politicians lose elections. When Republicans win, we're witnessing divine providence. When Republicans lose, we're witnessing cultural decay. God apparently operates an electoral college, and the Almighty's approval rating can be calculated by checking whether the candidate with an R beside his name won.
That's a remarkably efficient theological system. It eliminates the need for introspection, accountability, or the unpleasant possibility that millions of Americans simply looked at what Republicans were offering and decided they didn't want any more of it.
But perhaps I'm being unfair. Perhaps the nation's spiritual health really does depend on whether a particular political party controls the Texas governor's mansion. Maybe heaven maintains a dashboard of Republican victories, and every Democratic election result triggers an emergency meeting among the archangels.
I would love to see the minutes from that meeting.
When Democracy Works, Apparently It's a Medical Emergency
Here's the part that genuinely fascinates me. For years, conservative religious leaders have reminded Americans that voting is a sacred responsibility. They encourage congregations to register, participate, organize, and make their voices heard. They celebrate democracy as a defining feature of our national heritage, especially when the results agree with their preferences.
But when democracy delivers the wrong outcome, suddenly the electorate needs spiritual rehabilitation.
I find that interpretation suspiciously self-serving.
The people who voted Democratic in 2026 weren't necessarily rejecting Christianity, morality, family, or civilization. Many were rejecting a political party. There's a difference, although you'd never know it from some of the sermons delivered after Election Day.
A voter can believe in God and still oppose Donald Trump. A voter can attend church every Sunday and still think Republican immigration policies are unnecessarily cruel. A voter can believe in traditional marriage, own three Bibles, volunteer at a food pantry, and conclude that the Republican Party has become a traveling circus with remarkably expensive admission.
None of those positions requires an exorcism.
Yet some politically active evangelical leaders seem determined to interpret every Republican defeat as evidence that ordinary Americans have lost their moral compass.
Perhaps Americans haven't lost their moral compass. Perhaps they're using it.
Maybe they're looking at the economy, immigration enforcement, government priorities, political conduct, and the general condition of national leadership, then deciding that something needs to change.
That's not necessarily moral decay. Sometimes it's the entire point of having elections.
Democracy isn't a machine designed to validate the opinions of whichever religious leaders shout the loudest. It's a system in which citizens possess the extraordinary freedom to disagree, including with people who believe their political preferences have divine authorization.
And that freedom doesn't suddenly become a disease when someone exercises it incorrectly.
The Almighty Apparently Has a Political Action Committee
One of the more astonishing developments in modern American politics has been watching certain religious conservatives transform a political party into something resembling a subsidiary of the Kingdom of Heaven.
I don't remember reading about Jesus founding the Republican National Committee. Admittedly, the Bible is a long book, and perhaps I missed the chapter where the apostles debate tax policy and endorse a congressional candidate.
But I have a feeling I would remember.
What troubles me isn't that Christians participate in politics. They absolutely should. Religious people have the same rights as everyone else to vote, organize, advocate, criticize, and pursue political change. A healthy democracy benefits from moral perspectives informed by faith, philosophy, experience, and conscience.
What troubles me is the increasingly fashionable suggestion that one political coalition possesses exclusive ownership of Christian morality.
Because once you convince yourself that your preferred political party represents God's will, disagreement becomes something much more sinister than ordinary democratic opposition.
Your opponents aren't merely mistaken. They're corrupt. They're dangerous. They're enemies of civilization. Their electoral victories become evidence of spiritual contamination.
And conveniently, your own political mistakes become almost impossible to acknowledge.
If the Republican Party loses because America is morally diseased, then the Republican Party never has to ask whether its candidates were unpopular, its policies were harmful, or its messaging was insulting.
It can simply blame the patients.
Imagine visiting a physician who tells you that the treatment failed because your body was insufficiently loyal to the doctor. That's essentially the political analysis we're being offered, except the doctor's waiting room has patriotic decorations and a donation basket.
I don't need a theology degree to recognize the danger of confusing political allegiance with spiritual virtue.
Faith is supposed to challenge human arrogance, not provide it with a microphone.
Let's Talk About That Famous Moral Compass
If we're going to diagnose America's moral condition, I'd like to examine the credentials of the people conducting the examination.
Not their religious credentials. Their consistency.
For years, I've watched politically influential Christians demand that Americans care about character, personal responsibility, honesty, marital fidelity, humility, and respect for traditional values. These principles were presented as foundational to a functioning society.
Then Donald Trump became the central figure of Republican politics, and suddenly a surprising number of those standards acquired exceptions, footnotes, and emergency escape hatches.
Character mattered, unless the candidate delivered conservative judges. Personal conduct mattered, unless the candidate promised political victories. Humility mattered, unless the candidate's preferred communication style involved insulting everyone within microphone range.
Apparently, morality is like an airline baggage allowance. The rules depend on how important the passenger is.
I'm not suggesting every evangelical Christian abandoned their principles. Many didn't. Some publicly opposed Trump's conduct from the beginning, often at considerable social and political cost. Others have spent years trying to reconcile their conservative convictions with serious concerns about the movement's direction.
Those people deserve to be heard.
But the broader political contradiction remains impossible to ignore.
When religious leaders spend years explaining why certain behavior should disqualify a politician, only to discover that the same behavior becomes tolerable when committed by someone advancing their agenda, ordinary people notice.
They may not organize theological conferences about it. They may not publish lengthy doctrinal essays. They simply watch, listen, and quietly conclude that the rules aren't really rules.
They're preferences.
And preferences disguised as eternal principles have a nasty habit of destroying the credibility of the people promoting them.
Perhaps that credibility problem deserves a sermon before we begin diagnosing everyone else's soul.
The Numbers Don't Suggest a Mass Conversion to Evil
The election data makes the whole performance even more interesting.
According to the Houston Chronicle, citing NBC exit polling, approximately 82 percent of white evangelical or born-again Christian voters supported Republicans in 2026. That's the same percentage reported in 2024.
In other words, the voting preferences of this particular religious constituency didn't dramatically shift toward Democrats.
The bigger change involved its share of the electorate, which fell from roughly 23 percent in 2024 to 17 percent in 2026 in those exit polls.
Now, I'm no professional political consultant, but that sounds less like a nationwide outbreak of spiritual wickedness and more like a turnout problem combined with a broader political rejection of Republican leadership.
Apparently, however, the preferred response in certain corners of the movement is not to conduct an honest assessment of why people stayed home or voted differently.
It's to announce that the culture is diseased.
That seems like a strange recruitment strategy.
Imagine running a restaurant where customers have stopped showing up. You could examine the menu, reconsider your prices, improve the service, or ask whether your chef has developed a troubling habit of yelling at diners.
Or you could stand outside with a megaphone and announce that everyone in town is morally defective for refusing to eat your chicken.
I suspect the second approach would produce fewer reservations.
But perhaps political organizers know something restaurant owners don't.
Still, I can't help wondering whether constant predictions of national doom have become less persuasive precisely because Americans have heard them so many times.
When everything is an existential catastrophe, eventually people stop reaching for the emergency exits.
Sometimes they just change the channel.
Texas Didn't Abandon Christianity. It Voted for Different Politicians.
Texas offers an especially revealing example.
Democrat James Talarico defeated Republican Ken Paxton in the state's U.S. Senate race, while Democrats also achieved major victories elsewhere in a state long associated with Republican political dominance.
For some religious conservatives, Talarico's success seems particularly difficult to process because he doesn't fit their preferred explanation for why Democrats win.
He's openly Christian.
He discusses his faith. He talks about scripture, neighbors, moral obligations, and the relationship between religious belief and public service.
This presents an obvious theological inconvenience for anyone who has spent years telling voters that Christianity naturally points toward Republican candidates.
Because now there's a Democrat talking about Jesus without first requesting permission from the Republican Party.
The audacity.
Apparently, the trouble with a Christian Democrat is that he interferes with a very profitable political narrative.
It's much easier to portray an election as a battle between Christianity and secular hostility when the other candidate isn't standing there discussing Christianity from a different moral perspective.
Suddenly, people have to wrestle with actual disagreements about theology, policy, compassion, authority, and the proper relationship between church and state.
That sounds exhausting.
It requires thought.
It requires acknowledging that sincere Christians can interpret their religious obligations differently. It requires admitting that political disagreements don't automatically prove one side hates God.
And most dangerously of all, it requires recognizing that no political party owns Jesus.
I suspect that's the real problem for some political activists. Not that Christianity is disappearing, but that Christianity is refusing to remain neatly confined within their preferred political boundaries.
A faith that can inspire someone to vote Republican can also inspire someone to vote Democratic, support an independent candidate, or reject all available choices.
That's not necessarily a weakness in religion.
It might be evidence that religion is more complicated than a campaign brochure.
The Immigration Conversation Finally Reaches the Pulpit
One of the more revealing parts of the Houston reporting concerned immigration.
Pastor Steve Riggle of Grace Woodlands criticized the public image of Immigration and Customs Enforcement and expressed concern about the treatment of immigrants, including people brought to the United States as very young children.
He also maintained his opposition to open borders and supported deporting criminals.
I find that distinction important because it demonstrates something that frequently disappears from political shouting matches: a person can support immigration enforcement while questioning whether every enforcement practice is humane, proportionate, or consistent with the country's values.
Amazing, isn't it?
Nuance has survived another election.
Riggle's concerns are worth taking seriously, particularly because they come from within a politically conservative religious community. They're an example of a pastor examining policy consequences rather than simply treating party loyalty as a substitute for moral judgment.
Bruno Molina of the National Hispanic Baptist Network made another important observation. According to the Chronicle, many Hispanic Baptists remain theologically and politically conservative, but are unhappy about the effects of Trump's deportation policies on their communities.
Think about that for a moment.
These aren't necessarily people who suddenly embraced every progressive position in American politics. They may still hold deeply conservative views about abortion, marriage, religious doctrine, and the role of government.
But they also have families.
They have neighbors.
They have friends who may be living with fear, uncertainty, or the consequences of immigration enforcement.
They've experienced politics as something other than a cable-news debate.
And apparently, that experience influences how they vote.
Who could possibly have predicted that treating human beings like political abstractions might eventually produce electoral consequences?
It's almost as though voters have lives.
Maybe their political decisions aren't entirely determined by which party sends them the most religiously themed campaign literature.
Maybe compassion doesn't automatically disappear because someone happens to support lower taxes.
And maybe a political movement that wants religious voters to listen should spend less time accusing them of betrayal and more time listening to what they're saying.
I Keep Looking for the Part Where Jesus Endorsed Cruelty
One reason these conversations frustrate me is that Christianity contains powerful moral teachings about humility, mercy, charity, forgiveness, and care for vulnerable people.
I'm not claiming that every public policy question has a simple biblical answer. Immigration, taxation, criminal justice, national defense, and economic regulation involve competing responsibilities and difficult trade-offs.
Reasonable people, including Christians, can disagree about those questions.
But there is a difference between discussing policy honestly and pretending that cruelty becomes righteous whenever it's politically useful.
I find it difficult to reconcile the language of loving one's neighbor with a political culture that sometimes appears to take genuine pleasure in watching designated outsiders suffer.
It's hard to imagine the Sermon on the Mount being improved by a campaign consultant shouting that compassion is weakness and humiliation is an effective governing strategy.
Yet certain corners of contemporary religious politics seem extraordinarily comfortable celebrating aggression as strength.
They talk about righteousness as though it requires permanently clenched fists.
They praise forgiveness in church and demand vengeance in politics.
They celebrate humility on Sunday and cheer political arrogance on Monday.
Then they express astonishment when people begin questioning the sincerity of the whole arrangement.
I'm not suggesting that Christians should never be forceful, confront wrongdoing, or defend principles. Moral conviction sometimes requires uncomfortable courage.
But courage and cruelty aren't synonyms.
Neither are kindness and surrender.
If a political movement cannot distinguish between the two, perhaps the problem isn't that the country has lost its moral bearings.
Perhaps the movement needs to recalibrate its own.
When Did Political Disagreement Become Spiritual Treason?
Somewhere along the way, ordinary political disagreement became an accusation against a person's moral character.
Support a different immigration policy? You hate America.
Question the president? You're attacking Christianity.
Vote for a Democrat? Congratulations, you've apparently enrolled in the accelerated national decline program.
I would find this amusing if it weren't such a destructive way to approach democratic citizenship.
I've known good people with profoundly different political beliefs. I've encountered conservatives who volunteer their time helping strangers and liberals who do exactly the same thing. I've met religious people whose kindness is genuine and nonreligious people whose integrity could embarrass a room full of elected officials.
Human decency does not arrive with a party registration card.
And political affiliation doesn't tell me everything I need to know about someone's soul.
If anything, I've become increasingly suspicious of people who insist that their group has a monopoly on virtue.
The more loudly someone announces their moral superiority, the more interested I become in checking whether they practice it when no one is watching.
True moral authority doesn't require constant self-advertisement.
It becomes visible through conduct.
Which brings us back to the awkward problem facing religious leaders who have closely identified themselves with political power.
When you spend years attaching the credibility of your faith to the success of a political party, you shouldn't be surprised when the party's behavior begins influencing how outsiders perceive your faith.
That's not persecution.
That's association.
And associations have consequences.
Maybe the Church Should Stop Acting Like a Campaign Headquarters
Here's a radical suggestion: perhaps churches should focus on being churches.
I realize that's a controversial position in an era when almost everything becomes a political identity, including coffee preferences, athletic shoes, and whether someone likes electric vehicles.
But hear me out.
A church can address poverty without functioning as a Democratic campaign office. It can defend religious liberty without serving as a Republican field operation. It can teach about moral responsibility without instructing congregants which politicians have apparently been preapproved by heaven.
It can encourage people to think.
It can challenge members of its own congregation.
It can even criticize powerful politicians from the party its members generally support.
Imagine the possibilities.
A sermon about greed that applies equally to wealthy Democrats and wealthy Republicans. A discussion of honesty that doesn't include an exemption for whichever president currently occupies the White House. A message about human dignity that doesn't stop at the border or disappear when the person in question belongs to the wrong political coalition.
I understand that religious organizations have always influenced public life. That's not new, and I don't expect faith to retreat into some politically sterile corner of society.
But there's a difference between bringing moral principles into public debate and treating religious authority as a mechanism for partisan discipline.
One invites citizens to examine their conscience.
The other tells them their conscience has already been examined by party leadership.
And frankly, I don't trust political parties to handle that responsibility.
They can barely manage their own campaign promises.
The Other Christians Nobody Seems Interested in Hearing
There's another issue that gets overlooked whenever someone talks about the Christian response to Republican defeats.
Which Christians?
White evangelical conservatives are an important religious constituency, but they aren't the entire Christian population of the United States.
Black churches have rich political and theological traditions. Hispanic Christians bring diverse religious experiences and political priorities. Mainline Protestants, Catholics, Orthodox Christians, independent evangelicals, and countless other believers disagree with one another about everything from worship practices to public policy.
Their reactions to the same election can be dramatically different.
A Baptist News Global report highlighted how some Black Christian leaders viewed the 2026 Democratic victories with optimism while many white evangelical conservatives expressed grief and disappointment.
Consider the significance of that contrast.
Two groups can share belief in Christianity, read the same Bible, pray to the same God, and reach entirely different conclusions about an election.
That should make anyone cautious about claiming that a particular result represents God's approval or condemnation.
Because which group is supposedly interpreting heaven's political preferences correctly?
Are Republican victories divine blessings and Democratic victories spiritual warnings? Or does the equation reverse depending on who's standing behind the pulpit?
Perhaps this is why I resist attempts to turn election results into theological scorecards.
Political coalitions are human institutions. They're messy, compromised, ambitious, inconsistent, and frequently populated by people who couldn't recognize humility if it arrived wearing a name tag.
Religious faith deserves more serious consideration than reducing it to whichever party won the last election.
And democracy deserves better than treating half the electorate as spiritually defective whenever the vote totals become inconvenient.
The Problem With Constantly Predicting the End of Civilization
I also wonder whether religious political rhetoric has developed a serious addiction to catastrophe.
Every election is the most important election in history. Every cultural disagreement signals the imminent destruction of the nation. Every political setback becomes a terrifying milestone in America's journey toward moral ruin.
At some point, I'd like someone to explain when civilization was last operating correctly.
Was it twenty years ago? Fifty? A hundred?
Pick a year. I'll bring the history books.
Because America's past contains slavery, segregation, religious discrimination, political corruption, economic exploitation, violence, and an impressive collection of politicians who behaved terribly while praising their own moral excellence.
The country has accomplished extraordinary things, but it has never been a flawless moral paradise.
The idea that America recently fell from some universally righteous golden age requires a remarkable amount of selective memory.
And I suspect that's part of the appeal.
Nostalgia is easier than accountability.
It's comforting to imagine that everything was once good, that everything has now gone wrong, and that restoring the correct political leadership will somehow repair the human condition.
But real human problems don't disappear when a preferred candidate wins.
Greed doesn't vanish under Republican administrations. Cruelty doesn't evaporate under Democratic ones. Dishonesty doesn't check the party registration of the person practicing it.
Human nature remains stubbornly human.
That's why moral improvement requires something deeper than electoral victory.
It requires habits, institutions, humility, consistent principles, and a willingness to acknowledge uncomfortable truths.
Unfortunately, those things don't fit particularly well on campaign bumper stickers.
The Voters Aren't Obligated to Agree With the Sermon
I think some political leaders have forgotten a basic fact about democracy: voters are not employees.
They don't report to party officials.
They don't owe candidates unwavering loyalty.
They don't have to explain their personal political decisions to religious leaders who have decided that only one acceptable answer exists.
Their votes belong to them.
If voters dislike a candidate's character, that's their decision. If they reject a policy, that's their decision. If they think the governing party has failed to make their lives better, they're allowed to choose somebody else.
That's not an attack on the constitutional system.
It's the system working exactly as intended.
And if Republican politicians want those voters back, there's a remarkably straightforward approach available.
Give them something worth voting for.
Develop policies that address real problems. Recruit candidates who demonstrate competence and integrity. Stop treating criticism as betrayal. Recognize that citizens might have legitimate concerns that cannot be dismissed with accusations of moral decay.
Most importantly, stop confusing electoral rejection with evidence that the voters themselves are defective.
Nobody likes being told that their concerns about groceries, employment, healthcare, immigration, or national leadership are merely symptoms of spiritual confusion.
A parent struggling to pay bills doesn't necessarily want a lecture about the end of civilization.
They might prefer an explanation of how elected officials intend to make ordinary life more manageable.
I know that's less dramatic than predicting divine judgment.
But it might be more useful.
I Have a Different Diagnosis
So, is America sick?
In some respects, absolutely.
We have serious problems with political dishonesty, institutional distrust, social fragmentation, cruelty, economic insecurity, and the increasingly popular belief that anyone who disagrees with us must be morally inferior.
Those are genuine concerns.
But I don't believe a Democratic election victory is evidence of a spiritual epidemic any more than I believe a Republican victory constitutes proof of divine approval.
An election is a political event.
It can reveal public dissatisfaction, changing priorities, demographic shifts, weak candidates, failed policies, or countless other ordinary democratic forces.
It doesn't automatically reveal the medical condition of the national soul.
And when religious leaders turn political disappointment into a sweeping moral condemnation of society, they risk missing the very problems they're supposedly trying to address.
Perhaps the illness isn't that Americans are voting differently.
Perhaps it's that too many people have become incapable of accepting disagreement without declaring the other side evil.
Perhaps it's that political movements have learned to use religion as a shield against criticism rather than allowing religious principles to challenge their own behavior.
Perhaps it's that accountability has become something we demand from opponents while treating it as an intolerable insult when directed at ourselves.
Those seem like problems worth examining.
And unlike the supposed spiritual catastrophe of Democrats winning elections, they're problems we can actually work to improve.
Before Declaring America Sick, Try Looking in the Mirror
Here's what I'd like to hear from the religious leaders who are genuinely worried about the moral direction of the country.
I'd like them to ask whether they've been consistent.
I'd like them to examine whether their political commitments have made them more compassionate, more truthful, more humble, and more willing to defend the dignity of people outside their own communities.
I'd like them to consider whether their rhetoric brings people closer to the principles they preach or simply makes them feel justified in despising their neighbors.
And I'd like them to acknowledge that losing an election doesn't automatically mean the country has abandoned God.
Sometimes it means voters didn't like your candidates.
Sometimes it means your party failed to deliver.
Sometimes it means people are exhausted by the constant anger, the theatrical outrage, the moral lectures, and the endless insistence that civilization will collapse unless a particular collection of politicians remains in office.
Those possibilities may be unpleasant, but they're not particularly mysterious.
I'm not asking anyone to abandon religious convictions or surrender conservative principles. I'm asking for something considerably more challenging.
Consistency.
If honesty matters, it matters when your candidate lies. If kindness matters, it matters when your political allies behave cruelly. If integrity matters, it matters even when abandoning it would produce an attractive electoral advantage.
And if democracy matters, it matters when you lose.
I don't think that's an unreasonable standard.
I think it's the minimum standard we should expect from people claiming to possess superior moral insight.
The Houston pastors are free to believe America needs a spiritual awakening. Perhaps they're right that our society needs more reflection, compassion, and moral seriousness. I certainly wouldn't object to a country in which people were more honest, more generous, and less eager to treat their neighbors as enemies.
But any genuine awakening worth having should begin with self-examination, not simply a list of accusations against everyone who voted differently.
Because the strangest thing about this latest diagnosis of America's moral sickness is how conveniently it exempts the people delivering it.
The patients are always other people.
The problem is always the culture.
The responsibility always belongs to someone else.
And the cure, somehow, always involves putting the same political party back in charge.
That's not a spiritual diagnosis.
That's a campaign strategy wearing a clerical collar.
So before we declare the nation terminally ill because Republicans lost the midterms, perhaps we should consider a simpler possibility.
Millions of Americans went to the polls, considered their choices, and decided they wanted a different direction.
They didn't necessarily reject Christianity. They didn't necessarily abandon morality. They didn't necessarily declare war on traditional values.
They voted.
And if that ordinary exercise of democratic freedom is enough to convince some political pastors that America is dying, I would respectfully suggest they consult a second opinion.
Preferably from someone who understands the difference between losing an election and losing your religion.
Because if your faith can survive centuries of persecution, war, famine, plague, and profound human suffering, but apparently cannot survive a Democrat winning in Texas, I don't think the problem is America's spiritual health.
I think you've mistaken your political party for your religion.
And frankly, that sounds like a condition worth praying about.

Comments
Post a Comment